Barak Obama may be a damn good rhetoritician, but his politically correct use of pronouns is bugging me. Take this, from the July 22 press conference when he waded into the Henry Louis Gates-Sgt. Crowley brouhaha: “I think it’s fair to say, number one, any of us would be pretty angry; number two, that the Cambridge police acted stupidly in arresting somebody when there was already proof that they were in their own home.”
While pundits jumped on the President’s case for saying the Cambridge police acted “stupidly,” I muttered under my breath about his use of “they” when “he” or “she” was called for.
It may be the height of pettiness to demand grammatical perfection of presidents speaking off the cuff. But this isn’t the only time Obama has committed this particular gaff. In a pre-election commercial he said, “Every parent in America wants the same thing: good education for their child.”
Doesn’t a good education include grammar?
Now, I had the same English teachers as our president—at Punahou School, in Honolulu—and to be honest I can’t remember what grammar lessons we got there. But I know that somebody is one of those troublesome indefinite pronouns (like anyone, anybody, everyone, everybody, someone, somebody, no one, and nobody) that is always singular.
I also know that I’m wading into one of the subjects that can make word nerds—not the type usually prone to unbridled passions—go apoplectic. Some recite history and a seemingly infinite string of writers (everyone from Spenser to Shakespeare, from Austen to Auden, from Mark Twain to Rudyard Kipling) who use “they” as a singular pronoun. (See this screed at crossmyt.com.) Others (like Merriam-Webster’s) argue that if this is how people use the pronoun, we should all accept it. And others, like Grammar Girl, advise us to play it safe by recasting sentences.
I’m interested neither in political correctness nor grammatical hypercorrectness. I’m interested in clarity. Using “their” to refer to a single person blurs lines and introduces ambiguity.
So, Mr. President: We know that Gates is a guy. Don’t use grammar stupidly. Go ahead and say the police acted stupidly in arresting somebody when there was already proof that he was in his own home.
Related posts:
Posted in Blog | 4 Comments »
November 2nd, 2009 at 12:43 pm
Speaking of grammatical mishaps…I just heard Neal Conan on “Talk of the Nation” say, “…the results of the race is…”
November 2nd, 2009 at 2:04 pm
Great example, Sarah. Gives me a chance to be even MORE pedagogical.
In Obama’s case, the pronoun (their) doesn’t agree with its antecedent (somebody). In Conan’s case, the verb (is) doesn’t agree with its subject (results). Conan shoulda used “are.”
November 18th, 2009 at 6:27 am
Uh oh! Here’s Obama making the same mistake again, in The New Yorker (9/21/09, page 49). In an article titled “Bench Press,” about the president’s legal approach, Jeffrey Toobin quotes the former law professor:
“One of the roles of the courts is to protect people who don’t have a voice…. The vulnerable, the minority, the outcast, the person with the unpopular idea, the journalist who is shaking things up. That’s inherently the role of the court. And if somebody doesn’t appreciate that role, then I don’t think they are going to make a very good justice.”
November 20th, 2009 at 3:15 pm
[...] Bob Woodward read this blog? I just wrote about Barak Obama’s rogue pronouns a few weeks [...]